Notre Dame Pro-Abortion-Rights Professor Loses Libel Lawsuit Against Student Newspaper
An excerpt from the long opinion in Kay v. Irish Rover Inc., decided yesterday by Indiana Court of Appeals Judge Paul Mathias, joined by Judges Elaine Brown and Dana Kenworthy:
Dr. Tamara Kay appeals the St. Joseph Superior Court’s order granting The Irish Rover, Inc.’s, motion to dismiss her defamation claim…. On the dates the alleged defamation occurred, Dr. Kay was a tenured professor in the Keough School of Global Affairs and the Sociology Department at the University of Notre Dame. Her “academic research and teaching is focused on trade, labor, social movements, globalization, organizations, and global health which includes reproductive health and rights.” Many of Dr. Kay’s extensive writings in journals, newspapers, and on Twitter focus on advocating for abortion legalization.
The Irish Rover is an independent, student newspaper at the University. {[O]ne of its missions is to articulate and defend the Catholic character of the University.} …
After the United States Supreme Court decided Dobbs v. Jackson Woman’s Health Organization on June 24, 2022, Dr. Kay “became more outspoken on the issue of abortion access,” including more frequent posts on Twitter. On September 15, 2022, the Indiana General Assembly’s legislation limiting abortion in Indiana took effect, although it was enjoined shortly thereafter….
Kay sued over two articles published by the Irish Rover that concerned Dr. Kay’s speech. To oversimplify matters somewhat, under Indiana libel law, a libel claim based on speech on matters of public concern can only prevail based on a showing of knowing or reckless falsehood—mere negligence isn’t enough, even if plaintiff is a private figure. (In this respect, Indiana libel law is more speaker-protective than the constitutional minimum set forth by First Amendment law.) And here, the court concluded that the Rover’s statements were either true or at least reasonable interpretations of the facts that the Rover had, and certainly weren’t knowingly or recklessly false:
Here, we agree with the trial court that the undisputed facts established that The Irish Rover’s two articles were written in good faith and that the alleged defamatory statements were not false. The October 12, 2022, article is titled “Keough School Professor Offers Abortion Access to Students.” The article discusses a panel Dr. Kay participated in and her opinions on the ineffectiveness and immorality of abortion bans. The newspaper quoted Dr. Kay as stating that her “view runs afoul of Church teaching, but in other areas, [her] positions are perfectly aligned [with the Church.]”
The article included a photograph of the sign on Dr. Kay’s office door, which stated, “This is a SAFE SPACE to get help and information on ALL Healthcare issues and access – confidentially with care and compassion[.]” The sign also included the letter “J” in a circle, which the article recognized to “denote Notre Dame professors who are willing to help students access abortion.” In support of that statement, the article cited to a social media post where Dr. Kay stated, “‘[w]e are here (as private citizens, not representatives of ND) to help you access healthcare when you need it, and we are prep
Article from Reason.com
The Reason Magazine website is a go-to destination for libertarians seeking cogent analysis, investigative reporting, and thought-provoking commentary. Championing the principles of individual freedom, limited government, and free markets, the site offers a diverse range of articles, videos, and podcasts that challenge conventional wisdom and advocate for libertarian solutions. Whether you’re interested in politics, culture, or technology, Reason provides a unique lens that prioritizes liberty and rational discourse. It’s an essential resource for those who value critical thinking and nuanced debate in the pursuit of a freer society.
