Gender Equality Is Limited Public Figure for Purposes of Libel Lawsuit Over Her Performance
From Mason v. American Prospect, Inc., decided yesterday by Judge Loren L. AliKhan (D.D.C.):
Plaintiff Chataquoa Nicole Mason brings this action against Defendants The American Prospect (“TAP“) and Julianne McShane. Dr. Mason alleges that TAP and Ms. McShane defamed her and tortiously interfered with her business relations when they published an article (written and reported by Ms. McShane) covering her tenure as President and Chief Executive Officer of the Institute for Women’s Policy Research….
IWPR is a “national think tank” that “build[s] evidence to shape policies that grow women’s power and influence, close inequality gaps, and improve the economic well-being of families.” The organization was founded by Dr. Heidi Hartmann, who served as its long-time President and Chief Executive Officer. In 2019, IWPR’s Board of Directors removed Dr. Hartmann from these roles because she was “abusing staff and otherwise creating a toxic work environment, engaging in racist behavior … and failing to adequately fundraise.”
IWPR searched for a new President and Chief Executive Officer and hired Dr. Mason in fall 2019. Dr. Mason is an African American woman who holds a Ph.D. in Political Science, boasts “more than twenty years of research and advocacy experience focused on women’s economic security,” and has a “long track record of success in leadership positions.” She entered her new role in a time of tumult, facing budget shortfalls, staff discontentment, and racism. Nevertheless, “she worked tirelessly to achieve major goals,” like “dealing with the toxic work environment,” raising sorely needed funds (including closing a budget shortfall of more than one million dollars), and increasing the public profile of the organization. Dr. Mason “participate[d] in public forums and networking events,” “spearhead[ed] two major conferences,” won an industry award, and “was named one of the World’s Greatest Leaders by Fortune Magazine.” …
At some point, Ms. McShane, a freelance reporter, began investigating Dr. Mason’s leadership of IWPR…. In November 2022, TAP published the article, titled “A Women’s Policy Giant Struggles Amid New Leadership,” https://perma.cc/P9CY-3V3V. The article highlighted several of Dr. Mason’s and IWPR’s key accomplishments, including her recognition by Fortune magazine and IWPR’s successful fundraising efforts. The article also includes the following statements relevant to Dr. Mason’s claims:
- “[W]ithin weeks after this reporter sent Mason and two executive board members separate lists of detailed questions based on the reporting in this story, a law firm [was] retained by the board to assist with an independent review of IWPR’s workplace environment [and] began contacting former staffers for interviews, according to three sources.”
- “[Dr.] Mason fired Childers last fall after seven years at the organization … [and] did not respond to a specific inquiry about why Childers was fired.”
- “[R]ecords and interviews with former staffer
Article from Reason.com
The Reason Magazine website is a go-to destination for libertarians seeking cogent analysis, investigative reporting, and thought-provoking commentary. Championing the principles of individual freedom, limited government, and free markets, the site offers a diverse range of articles, videos, and podcasts that challenge conventional wisdom and advocate for libertarian solutions. Whether you’re interested in politics, culture, or technology, Reason provides a unique lens that prioritizes liberty and rational discourse. It’s an essential resource for those who value critical thinking and nuanced debate in the pursuit of a freer society.