Blocking Dissenters from School System’s “StaffPride” Twitter Account May Have Violated First Amendment
From yesterday’s opinion by Judge Paula Xinis (D. Md.) in Foldi v. Bd. of Ed. for Montgomery County:
Foldi and Mandel live in Montgomery County, Maryland. Foldi writes for a news magazine, The Spectator, and Mandel is a columnist for several national publications and has written extensively on education and parental rights. Id. In October 2022, the School Board announced the introduction of LGBTQIA+-themed books into the MCPS [Montgomery County Public Schools] curriculum. In response, several parents sought permission from MCPS for their children to “opt out” of any classroom instruction involving these books.
At first, it appeared that MCPS would permit this opt-out alternative. On March 22, 2023, MCPS confirmed that parents could choose to have their children read other material in lieu of the LGBTQIA+ books. But the next day, the School Board reversed course and informed parents that no such opt-out alternative would be available, nor would MCPS notify parents when classroom instruction would involve LGBTQIA+-themed materials….
The question of LGBTQIA+-inclusive reading materials became a hot button issue for MCPS. At a March 2023 School Board meeting for example, one parent vocally opposed the Board’s refusal to provide an opt-out alternative to parents on behalf of their children. In response, Board Member Harris challenged the protestor, publicly announcing that the parent’s position “is just telling that kid, ‘here’s another reason to hate another person.'”
Over the next few months, the debate over the propriety of the opt-out alternative intensified, and in advance of a June 6, 2023, School Board meeting, “scores of parents and community members” gathered in peaceful protest outside of the MCPS Carver Educational Services Center (“Carver Center”), where the meeting was being held. Also at the June 6th meeting, a female Muslim student attested to her discomfort with being made to read LGBTQIA+ books that ran contrary to her religious beliefs, to which Board Member Harris said she “felt kind of sorry” for the student, and opined about whether the student was “parroting [the] dogma” of her parents.
Predictably, these exchanges were the subject of ever-increasing media attention. Plaintiffs, in turn, planned to attend the next School Board meeting in person to oppose the use of LGBTQIA+-themed books and the denial of an opt-out alternative. Parents also planned to rally at the meeting to support an opt-out policy.
MCPS scheduled the next School Board meeting for June 27, 2023, and published the agenda a week in advance. The agenda made clear that the opt-out policy would b
Article from Latest
The Reason Magazine website is a go-to destination for libertarians seeking cogent analysis, investigative reporting, and thought-provoking commentary. Championing the principles of individual freedom, limited government, and free markets, the site offers a diverse range of articles, videos, and podcasts that challenge conventional wisdom and advocate for libertarian solutions. Whether you’re interested in politics, culture, or technology, Reason provides a unique lens that prioritizes liberty and rational discourse. It’s an essential resource for those who value critical thinking and nuanced debate in the pursuit of a freer society.