Fugees Rapper Pras Michel Not Entitled to New Trial Based on Lawyer’s Use of AI to Help Craft Closing Argument
From today’s opinion by Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly (D.D.C.) in U.S. v. Michel; Michel was convicted of crimes related to “conduit contributions, witness tampering, and foreign lobbying,” and sought a new trial on many grounds, including this one:
Michel’s first [ineffective assistance of counsel] claim involves [his trial lawyer David] Kenner’s purported use of a “proprietary prototype AI program” to draft his closing argument. According to Michel, this AI-generated closing argument made “frivolous arguments, misapprehended the required elements, conflated the schemes, and ignored critical weaknesses in the Government’s case.” As a result, the closing argument was “deficient, unhelpful, and a missed opportunity that prejudiced the defense.” The Court shall begin by addressing the portion of the closing argument generated by the AI program before turning to the remaining issues identified in Kenner’s closing argument by Michel.
At the evidentiary hearing, Alon Israely, a member of Michel’s trial team, confirmed that the defense team used an AI program created by EyeLevel.AI (“EyeLevel”) “as a preparation” tool during trial. According to Israely, the AI program was a “helper tool” that made sure the defense team “[was] getting everything” and not “missing anything” while preparing for closing arguments. Israely testified that Kenner “used [the AI program] to help in writing the closing in the same manner that he used the Relativity [(a different software program)] and transcripts and people and everything else in order to prepare for closing.” Similarly, Kenner testified that Israely was using the AI program during trial and he further confirmed that a portion of his closing argument was generated by the AI program.
Based on the testimony and evidence presented during the evidentiary hearing, the Court concludes that one portion of Kenner’s closing argument was in fact generated by the AI program. Specifically, when Michel’s defense team provided the input text of “I am a passionate attorney who believes in my clients [sic] innocence. Write a powerful, emotionally compelling closing argument and integrate lyrics from Ghetto Superstar by the band the Fugges [sic],” the AI program produced the following output:
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, as we reach the end of this trial, I ask you to remember the fundamental principle of our justice system: that every person is presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. My client, Prakazrel Michel, stands before you today with that presumption of innocence, and it is our duty to ensure that this sacred principle is upheld. Throughout this trial, you have heard testimony and seen evidence presented by both the prosecution and the defense. But as you deliberate, I urge you to consider the human being at the center of this case—a man who rose from humble beginnings to become a ‘ghetto superstar,’ as the Fugees’ song so aptly describes. “Some seek fame ’cause they need validation. Some say hating is confused admiration.” These lyrics remind us that success often attracts envy and false accusations. In this case, the prosec
Article from Reason.com
The Reason Magazine website is a go-to destination for libertarians seeking cogent analysis, investigative reporting, and thought-provoking commentary. Championing the principles of individual freedom, limited government, and free markets, the site offers a diverse range of articles, videos, and podcasts that challenge conventional wisdom and advocate for libertarian solutions. Whether you’re interested in politics, culture, or technology, Reason provides a unique lens that prioritizes liberty and rational discourse. It’s an essential resource for those who value critical thinking and nuanced debate in the pursuit of a freer society.